Microsoft Teams vs. Groups vs. SharePoint: Pros and Cons (and When to Use Which)

An oldie but a goodie- and still relevant as user are still confused.  Courtesy of SherWeb blog

It can be hard to keep up with Office 365’s ever-changing ecosystem. New applications are constantly released and their features can begin to feel the same. Even if specific products look distinct, you might still wonder what exactly the difference is between them.  It’s not always easy to choose one over another. Let’s examine some pros and cons for the three applications, and then we’ll look at typical applications of each.

Learn everything you need to know to become the ultimate Microsoft Teams reseller.

Pros and Cons

Teams: Microsoft’s answer to Slack

Microsoft has been making quite a fuss about this new application. It integrates with Groups, the previous poster child for “empowering teams within a company,” and offers channels to allow discussions of different subject areas.

Pros:

  • Valuable for small projects.
  • Excellent for departments that need fast replies for collaboration on daily tasks.
  • User-friendly interface.

Cons:

  • Tracking and reporting data is not as efficient as a SharePoint list.
  • Requires installing a local desktop application for an optimal experience.

SharePoint: More Than Just Document Collaboration

Most people think first about SharePoint’s document collaboration features, but it includes some other useful features that your company may find practical.

Pros:

  • Good when you need to collaborate using specific items (tickets, documents, inventory).
  • Generates reports and integrates with PowerBI.
  • Integrates custom applications.

Cons:

  • Requires advanced technical skills to develop and manage.
  • Setup needs to be done correctly from the start; if you make mistakes with things like permissions or membership access, it can be tricky to resolve access issues later on.

Groups: Multiple Features in Once Place

Office 365 Modern Groups, as it is called by the Microsoft Support team, was the first successful attempt by Microsoft to create a collaboration feature within Office 365 that provides email content, calendar sharing and storage space.

One of the best features of Groups is that when a meeting gets created for a group of which you are a member, it will automatically replicate in your calendar with a different name so you know it comes from the group’s calendar. This allows you to work on a shared calendar on your mobile device. As you know, shared calendars currently cannot be accessed on mobile, unless using the web version via browser. But here the meetings sync to your business calendar with tags.

Pros:

  • Shared calendar visible on mobile device apps.
  • Multiple applications in one place, all used for collaboration: distribution group, planner, OneNote, etc.
  • Easy to create and manage by users.

Cons:

  • Doesn’t include advanced features of SharePoint Document libraries, like versioning, views, metadata and workflow.

Applications

Now let’s look at some specific situations where each of these three applications can be most effective.

SharePoint

Vacation Planner

Let’s say that your company currently has a vacation planning process where employees go to HR, request the days they need off, fill in the correct paperwork, get approval from their manager, and then submit the request again. This can take up to 30-45 minutes, even if everything goes smoothly.

Instead, you can set up a List in SharePoint and combine it with a Calendar. With the new Microsoft Flow you can set up a process so that any new request automatically goes to the manager for approval and HR can get the data they need from the list. This can slash the time required for vacation planning by 50% or more, greatly improving productivity.

Task Handoff

Suppose you have two teams working in shifts, and certain tasks or tickets need to be handed off from one to another. Usually this is done over email, but this can be clunky and difficult to track and manage. You can instead set up a project task list where people can have parts of the project assigned to them. Once a task is completed, the person that finished it marks it complete, and the project can go on. This makes tasks very easy to track, report and manage.

Teams

Collaboration Between Tiers

Let’s say you have a support department with Level 1, Level 2 and Level 3 teams, with requests funneled to the appropriate level depending on the complexity of the issue.

With Teams, a Level 1 support person who needs assistance can ensure that the question is seen by all members in Level 2 support, and get a reply to it. If the question requires additional communication with the next level, they can then be included in the discussion.

Organize Projects Better

Your team often works on projects with multiple people assigned to different roles. In Teams you can assign people to a task, or tag them. They will get an email notification and can collaborate using OneNote.

When you need to do a presentation and have several people working on it, each doing different subtasks, it’s easy for you to tag and track each person in the channel. They can then upload their work and you can review it in the subchannel created for them. If at any point they require assistance from a colleague, they can tag that person to send an email notification. This allows you to maintain an overview on what each person is doing.

Groups

Unified Mailbox for a Department

Read more

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.